Supreme Court Rules Aereo as illegal, Victory for Nation’s Biggest Television Broadcasters

(Attorney Paul Clement)

(Attorney Paul Clement)

On Wednesday, the U.S. Supreme Court reached a 6-3 decision against TV streaming service Aereo, which held that the company’s technology of allowing subscribers stream and record broadcast TV without the broadcaster’s permission violated the Copyright Act.

Justices ruled that Aereo is tantamount to a cable company, not merely an equipment provider. Cable companies normally rebroadcast over-the-air TV signals to their subscribers through their existing networks. To do this the companies must pay a retransmission fee to the content creators, allowing them to provide without infringing on the networks’ copyright. Aereo operates by renting individual TV antennas to each subscriber and then beaming that signal to the subscribers phone or tablet allowing them to record and playback shows. Under copyright law, Aereo argued that it was same as private performance of shows and hence not subject to retransmission fees.

Currently in 11 markets, Aereo uses dime-sized antennas to scoop up the freely available over-the-air local TV broadcasts and feed them to subscribers through the Internet. Users pay an $8 monthly fee for the service. For an additional $4, subscribers can get 20 hours of DVR storage, or for $12 per month, 60 hours of DVR storage.

It’s a remarkable triumph for broadcasters such as CBS, NBC, Fox, ABC and allies such as the NFL, which argued that Aereo captures networks’ signals and would have driven broadcasters and major sports out of over-the-air transmissions to secure their intellectual property. They said the ruling is a victory for consumers.

Usually, service providers are not held responsible for what their subscribers do with their service. For instance, a cloud storage service such as Dropbox cannot be held responsible if an individual uses its service to allow others to download copyrighted material. According to the ruling, the fact that Aereo was just providing the antennas and delivering the transmissions captured by those antennas did not exonerate them of responsibility for the copyrighted content that was being transmitted.

The ruling will most likely shut down affordable content streaming services like Aereo. It was obviously the price that was drawing users to Aereo instead of traditional cable service. As Aereo will now be required to pay the costly retransmission fees, the cost will be apparently passed on to subscribers, resulting in the service being far more expensive than the present $8 per month, so the business model is likely no longer supportable. The decision is likely to affect several similar service providers as well.

 

 

Anna Domanska
Anna Domanska is an Industry Leaders Magazine author possessing wide-range of knowledge for Business News. She is an avid reader and writer of Business and CEO Magazines and a rigorous follower of Business Leaders.

Recent Posts

Some Microsoft employees stayed at data centers during Pandemic to keep all systems going

Some Microsoft employees stayed at data centers during Pandemic to keep all systems going

The Covid-19 pandemic ravaging the world for more than a year has forced companies and organizations to find viable solutions to keep the business going. Most found a solution in w
11 hours ago
Meme stocks frenzy and 3 companies to follow

Meme stocks frenzy and 3 companies to follow

The doom and gloom about the stock market that has been predicted since the pandemic started has abated somewhat with the resilience shown by investors (helped by low-interest rate
11 hours ago
US Space Force allows repurposed SpaceX rocket to launch GPS satellite

US Space Force allows repurposed SpaceX rocket to launch GPS satellite

A GPS navigation satellite built by Lockheed Martin is set to ride a reused SpaceX booster on a launch from Cape Canaveral, Florida, Thursday. It will be the first time a military
19 hours ago
Disney boss says 40 pc ad revenue went to streaming sites, no plans of ad supported Disney+

Disney boss says 40 pc ad revenue went to streaming sites, no plans of ad supported Disney+

Walt Disney CEO Bob Chapel says the company’s advertising revenue for the upcoming fall television season was strong and went up by “double-digits” compared to 2019.
2 days ago
BlackRock ETFs breach $3 trillion mark in May

BlackRock ETFs breach $3 trillion mark in May

BlackRocks’ exchange-traded fund crossed $3 trillion for the first time in May, in sync with the ETF industry’s race to an all-time high of $9 trillion.
3 days ago
Flagship Pioneering, investor in Moderna raises $3.4 billion funds

Flagship Pioneering, investor in Moderna raises $3.4 billion funds

Flagship Pioneering, the bioplatform company, and the venture capital investor in Moderna, today announced that it had raised additional funding of $2.23 billion, which brings its
4 days ago