Singapore watchdog imposes heavy fines on Uber-Grab merger

The Singapore’s competition regulatory body has fined San Francisco-based Uber Technologies Inc. and domestic company, GrabTaxi Holdings Ltd. S$13 million (US$9.5 million) over their anti-competitive merger deal. The Uber-Grab merger took place in March this year with which the former ride-hailing service moved out of Southeast Asia to cut potential losses.

The Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore (CCCS) had fined individually Uber S$6.58 million (US$4.8 million) and Grab S$6.4 million (US$4.7 million) to “deter completed, irreversible mergers that harm competition”.

The decision came after months of investigations on the impact of Uber-Grab merger deal on Singapore’s economy, reported TechCrunch. Despite the huge charges, Uber-Grab merger deal need not collapse, said the commission.

Uber-Grab Merger

Under the reign of CEO Dara Khosrowshahi, Uber has undergone a radical makeover. It is working on three goals simultaneously – diminish revenue losses by opting out of loss-making territories and businesses; focus on cash cows – American and European ride-hailing and food delivery businesses; and create a profitable brand image ahead of planned 2019 IPO.

Uber, earlier in March, agreed to sell its ride-hailing services, food delivery operations and payment solutions of Southeast Asia to the rival Grab, in exchange of 27.5 percent stake. The sold-off region included the Philippines, Myanmar, Malaysia, Cambodia, Thailand, Singapore, Vietnam, and Indonesia.

CCCS Investigations

According to TechCrunch, just days after the announcement of the merger, the Singapore competition watchdog found that Grab had increased the prices by 10-15 percent, while its market share rose to 80 percent in the domestic region.

Toh Han Li, Chief Executive of the commission said, “Mergers that substantially lessen competition are prohibited and CCCS has taken action against the Grab-Uber merger because it removed Grab’s closest rival, to the detriment of Singapore drivers and riders.”

The CCCS has now ordered Grab to restore its prices and commission rates levied before the merger, and eliminate exclusivity clause with taxi operators in Singapore, noted Financial Times. It also directed Uber to sell-off cars belonging to Lion City Rentals.

The Singapore ride-hailing service provider on Sunday produced a statement citing that it had been compliant with the authority during the entire review process. The note also highlighted that the company did not enter any anti-competitive activity intentionally.

There was no word heard from Uber on this entire subject till the time of publication.

Uber-Grab merger

Uber, earlier in March, agreed to sell its ride-hailing services of Southeast Asia to the rival Grab, in exchange of 27.5 percent stake. Source: Grab

Grab Counter-Arguments

Grab, however, reiterated about the watchdog’s “narrow” approach towards the term, ‘competition’.

“It is unfortunate that the CCCS is taking a very narrow market definition in arriving at its conclusion that the Transaction has led to a substantial lessening of competition,” as written in the statement. “Commuters are free to choose between street-hail taxis and private hire cars, and it is a fact that private-hire car drivers’ incomes are directly impacted by intense competition with street-hail taxis.”

Other than Grab, the citizens of Singapore can opt for ride-hailing service of either Ryde or TADA.

Meanwhile, sources close to Grab said that the current fines may not have a significant impact on the company’s balance sheet. This is so because Grab was valued nearly $11 billion at the last funding session led by Toyota.

Avatar
Carrie Ann
Carrie Ann is Editor-in-Chief at Industry Leaders Magazine, based in Las Vegas. Carrie covers technology, trends, marketing, brands, productivity, and leadership. When she isn’t writing she prefers reading. She loves reading books and articles on business, economics, corporate law, luxury products, artificial intelligence, and latest technology. She’s keen on political discussions and shares an undying passion for gadgets. Follow Carrie Ann on Twitter, Facebook & Google.

Recent Posts

Morgan Stanley raises CEO James Gorman’s pay to $33 million

Morgan Stanley raises CEO James Gorman’s pay to $33 million

James Gorman’s salary ($33 million) is comprised of four parts: a base salary of $1.5 million; a deferred equity award of $7.875 million; ...
4 hours ago
IBM Q4 Profit Up, Banks on Cloud and AI For 2021

IBM Q4 Profit Up, Banks on Cloud and AI For 2021

IBM’s revenue is expected to rise in 2021 and generate adjusted free cash flow of $11 billion to $12 billion for the year. ...
21 hours ago
‘World first’: Google threatens to disable search in Australia over proposed new law

‘World first’: Google threatens to disable search in Australia over proposed new law

Google has been at odds with the Australian Government since the latter proposed the ‘world first’ law to make tech companies pay publis...
23 hours ago
FCC rejects petition to stay Ligado Network’s 5G rollout

FCC rejects petition to stay Ligado Network’s 5G rollout

The Federal Communications Commission rejected by a vote of 3-2 on Tuesday to freeze the rollout of Ligado Networks’ nationwide mobile bro...
2 days ago
Oil prices rise on hopes of big stimulus money

Oil prices rise on hopes of big stimulus money

The crude oil prices showed an upswing with Brentwood going up to $56.08 a barrel and the US West Texas Intermediate crude oil selling at $5...
2 days ago
Kia bags Apple Car production deal

Kia bags Apple Car production deal

Apple Inc.’s much-coveted Apple Car could be produced by Kia Corp. at the latter’s manufacturing facility in the United States. The Sout...
2 days ago