Samsung phones cleared by US court causing Apple setback

J.K. Shin, head of Samsung Electronics Co.'s telecom division

J.K. Shin, head of Samsung Electronics Co.'s telecom division

An appeals court in the U.S. had the ban against Samsung Electronics Co. lifted according to the latest reports that were released. The ban on the Samsung Galaxy Nexus smartphone sale was lifted thereby causing a setback to Apple Inc. in the ongoing battle of the company against Google Inc. and its highly popular mobile software.

The Report:

Apple Inc. has waged wars against Google Inc. on various fronts, whose famous Android software does power most of the devices of Samsung Electronics Co. The ruling from the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in the U.S. on the Samsung Galaxy Nexus smartphone sale is however not quite expected to have a deep impact on the market of the smartphones. This is simply due to the fact that the Samsung Galaxy Nexus smartphone from the Samsung Electronics Co. is quite an aging product in the long line of products of the company. This ruling however caused a setback to Apple Inc. with its stocks closing down by nearly 2% at $628.10.

The market point of view:

With the ban against Samsung Electronics Co. lifted, it would be a bit hard for the other companies who tend to sue their competitors over patents in a bid to get their products pulled out of the market. This is what Colleen Chien, who is a professor with the Law School at Santa Clara in Silicon Valley, thinks about the matter. This kind of injunctions on the sales is a key for some of the companies in their efforts to increase their advantage in the patent fights at the courtrooms. The company declined to comment to the setback to Apple Inc. while there was no response from Samsung Electronics Co. as well. Apple Inc. had incidentally registered a great legal victory on Samsung Electronics Co. in the month of August when it was awarded a sum of as much as $1.05 billion in regard for damages. In that case a jury from the U.S. found that Samsung Electronics Co. was guilty of copying some critical features of the highly popular iPad and iPhone from Apple Inc. The case against the Samsung Galaxy Nexus smartphone sale was registered by Apple Inc. sometime around the earlier part of this year.

The Judgment of the Court:

Earlier district judge Lucy Koh in the month of June had issued a pre-trial injunction on the Samsung Galaxy Nexus smartphone sale. The Federal Circuit however in its judgment had the ban against Samsung Electronics lifted and stated the fact that Koh had abused her discretion. The judgment was a setback to Apple Inc. who failed to prove their point that the Samsung Galaxy Nexus smartphone sale was due to their infringing technology. The case has now been sent back to Koh for further reconsideration by the appeals court. Samsung Electronics Co. has a whole new set of smartphones and tablets in queue to be launched just before the beginning of the holidays. According to Eric Schmidt, the executive chairman of Google Inc., their fight against Apple Inc. is in most likelihood going to define the future of the mobile industry.

Aubrey Chang
Aubrey Chang, Associate Editor Industry Leaders Magazine (www.industryleadersmagazine.com)

Recent Posts

Flagship Pioneering, investor in Moderna raises $3.4 billion funds

Flagship Pioneering, investor in Moderna raises $3.4 billion funds

Flagship Pioneering, the bioplatform company, and the venture capital investor in Moderna, today announced that it had raised additional funding of $2.23 billion, which brings its
20 hours ago
United to recall furloughed employees as travel recovers

United to recall furloughed employees as travel recovers

The fading of the pandemic and the rollout of vaccines has brought in some good cheer for the floundering air travel industry. More countries have opened up for business and are al
2 days ago
UK’s Sanne agrees to consider Cinven bid

UK’s Sanne agrees to consider Cinven bid

Sanne, a UK fund administration business that provides alternative asset and corporate services, has agreed to hold talks with private equity firm Cinven over a potential £1.4bn t
2 days ago
Global stocks rise as investors ignore inflations indicators

Global stocks rise as investors ignore inflations indicators

Global stocks rose to an all-time high, with investor showing confidence in a strong economic recovery from coronavirus and the vaccine effect, but the market is still a bit cautio
2 days ago
UK watchdog whacks Amazon with probe for unfair data collection practices

UK watchdog whacks Amazon with probe for unfair data collection practices

The Competition and Markets Authority will focus on whether Amazon, Inc. favors merchants that use its delivery services.
5 days ago
Altice buys 12 percent stake in BT worth £2 billion

Altice buys 12 percent stake in BT worth £2 billion

Altice said it did not intend to make a bid for the British Telecoms company, though the takeover code also does not allow it to make an unsolicited buyout offer for six months wit
5 days ago