Johnson & Johnson seeks Supreme Court intervention in Talc case

Johnson & Johnson is appealing for a review by the Supreme Court of an award of $2 billion to a group of women who claimed they developed ovarian cancer from using the company's talc products.



Johnson & Johnson is appealing for a review by the Supreme Court of an award of $2 billion to a group of women who claimed they developed ovarian cancer from using the company’s talc products.

The company says it did not get a fair trial in a state court in Missouri that initially awarded $4.7 billion in favor of 22 women who said the asbestos used in the talc products led to their ovarian cancer. An appeal in the state court cut the rewarded payment by half to $2 billion.

The case has attracted much high-profile interest with former independent counsel Kenneth Starr representing the women. Johnson & Johnson is witnessing support from the nations’ big businesses.

The Supreme Court could give its decision on involvement with the case on Tuesday itself.

Momenta Johnson & Johnson acquisition

A photo of Johnson & Johnson headquarters.

In the Missouri state court appeal case, Judge Rex M. Burlison wrote that evidence at the trial showed “particularly reprehensible conduct on the part of Defendants.”

He said, despite being aware of the presence of asbestos in its talc, the company touted it as safe for use amongst babies and women and it “misrepresented the safety of these products for decades.”

Nine of the group of 22 women have died from ovarian cancer, lawyers for the plaintiffs said.

Johnson & Johnson denies that its talc products cause cancer, and it said that the Missouri trial verdict was “at odds with decades of independent scientific evaluations confirming Johnson’s Baby Powder is safe, is not contaminated by asbestos and does not cause cancer.” 

The company is facing 21,800 cases in the US for its use of asbestos in its talcum powder and its carcinogenic properties. Talc’s mineral structure is similar to asbestos. The cosmetics industry in 1976 agreed to make sure its talc products do not contain detectable amounts of asbestos.

A U.S. government-led analysis of 250,000 women in a study released last year found no strong evidence linking baby powder with ovarian cancer, though the study’s lead author called the results “very ambiguous.”

The Journal of the American Medical Association wrote in an editorial about the study that it was “overall reassuring”. It also added that the study was not definitive and a large comparable study was now not feasible as a similar number of women using talcum powder is not available now as most do not use powder for personal hygiene.

The New Brunswick New Jersey-based company has discontinued the sale of its Johnson & Johnson baby powder in the US and Canada citing dwindling numbers due to misinformation.

The case in the Missouri court is not about cancer-causing properties but more on a technicality. J&J claims that it should not have to face a trial against claims by women from 12 states with varying histories of using Johnson & Johnson products containing talc.

The big business and organizations backing J&J include the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and trade associations, insurers and the pharmaceutical industry.

Starr said in an interview with The Associated Press that none of Johnson & Johnson’s legal arguments is worth the court’s time. “As the jury found and as every judge to review this six-week trial record has concluded, Johnson & Johnson’s conduct over decades was reprehensible,” Starr said.

Anna Domanska
Anna Domanska is an Industry Leaders Magazine author possessing wide-range of knowledge for Business News. She is an avid reader and writer of Business and CEO Magazines and a rigorous follower of Business Leaders.

Recent Posts

Why Is Squid Game So Popular?

Why Is Squid Game So Popular?

The Squid Game segments were watched by at least 132 million people in the first 23 days of the show on Netflix. Know what excited the viewers.
12 hours ago
Amazon under Congressional scrutiny for pushing own products over others

Amazon under Congressional scrutiny for pushing own products over others

US judiciary Antitrust Committee writes a letter saying that Amazon is given time till November 1 to prove that it utilizes seller data available to create competing products and p
2 days ago
Porsche’s Taycan EV outsells ICE powered its 911 sports car

Porsche’s Taycan EV outsells ICE powered its 911 sports car

The Porsche Taycan EV has outsold the Porsche 911 sports car for the first time since it was introduced in 2019 by the German automaker.
2 days ago
Tesla expected to make a killing in Bitcoin profits in next earning report

Tesla expected to make a killing in Bitcoin profits in next earning report

The price of Bitcoins has rallied to another high in October after hitting around $64,800 in April. This time it has hit over $58,000 on Oct. 14.
3 days ago
Tesla Cybertruck V/s Rivian’s R1T

Tesla Cybertruck V/s Rivian’s R1T

The Tesla Cyberturck left many disappointed with its alien space ship-like design; though both trucks are still under production, what matters most is what comes under the hood.
5 days ago
College sports is multibillion dollar industry in the US

College sports is multibillion dollar industry in the US

According to data analyzed by GOBankingRates, head football coaches, closely followed by basketball coaches, easily rack up seven-figure salaries in the US.
6 days ago