Concept of country’s debt revised

The idea of a country's debt has been revised

The idea of a country's debt has been revised

The continued financial crisis in large and small economies across the world, has led to academics revisiting the concept of debt in the context of borrowing. Currently, the US debt is 74 percent of its GDP and analysts predict that the numbers will remain the same in the next ten years, causing a lot of concern for both sides: policy makers and taxpayers.

Growth in Time of Debt

Therefore as part of the worldwide debate and discussions on the level of borrowing that a country should seek external funds, a seminal economic paper by Harvard economists Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff, called “Growth in the Time of Debt,” provided valuable insights. According to their  widely-known and popular theory, countries that had high debt levels were found to have slow growth levels – in comparison with countries with lower debt levels.

Many decision makers were highly influenced by these findings, including the US government which adopted the practice of austerity and opted for cutting back on spending. The fact that the US government was definitely influenced was well summarized by Quartz’s Fernholz : “It’s hard to get bipartisan agreement on anything in the Senate, but you can see influential legislators from both parties were listening closely to the two economists as they engaged in key debates over the economy. Even the notoriously obstreperous Coburn noted that ‘there was remarkable agreement about the severity of the problem.”

Other Economists differ

Economists such as Hardon,Pollin and Ash differ on the Reinhart and Rogoff’s findings. According to the trio, for country in debt of 90 percent, the GDP growth is likely to be only around 2.2 percent each year and not -0.1 percent as it was found by the Harvard duo.

Surprisingly, a student recognized a basic error in a spreadsheet the duo used to base their findings. Though this has proved to be an embarrassment, the fact is now well established that there was an error in the findings by Reinhart and Rogoff.

Even though the duo did respond to the new discoveries, they did not directly dwell on the error in the calculations in their initial responses. They only justified that their paper too reiterated that the countries with higher debt would have low growth rates and lower debt levels would imply higher growth rates.

Nor did they respond directly to the ‘issue of causation’.

However later clarifications by the duo have been issued and they have admitted that the conclusions drawn by the new paper do point to errors that do not bear any significant impact on the end result of their paper. They have, however, proposed that the considerations by the trio focus on extra-ordinary events such as post-world war  and therefore more research consistent with the parameters the duo used will lead to similar conclusions.

However, the academic debate leaves the taxpayer wanting as their concern grows on how safe it is for their country to borrow and to what level.

Avatar
Jay Raol

Recent Posts

Moderna forecasts $18.4 billion revenue for 2021

Moderna forecasts $18.4 billion revenue for 2021

Moderna Inc., the Boston-based biotech startup, reported its fourth quarter and 2020 fiscal year results, where it announced that it hoped t...
10 hours ago
Hyundai Motor recalls 81,000 EVs for battery defect, may prove to be the costliest recall

Hyundai Motor recalls 81,000 EVs for battery defect, may prove to be the costliest recall

Hyundai Motor says the vehicle recalls are expected to cost the company about 1 trillion won or an estimated $900 million. In South Korea, 2...
11 hours ago
Accor reports $2.5 billion loss, hopeful of a recovery by next year

Accor reports $2.5 billion loss, hopeful of a recovery by next year

Accor, Europe’s largest hotel chain, reported a $2.5 billion net loss in 2020 due to the deterioration in the industry linked to the sprea...
1 day ago
Is the sun shining again on AMC stock?

Is the sun shining again on AMC stock?

As the old adage goes, good things come to those who wait. This might come true for movie theatre operator AMC Entertainment Holdings Inc. w...
1 day ago
HSBC turns to Asia for future growth

HSBC turns to Asia for future growth

The bank’s maximum pre-tax benefits (90%) come from its Asian business. Chairman Mark Tucker and chief executive Noel Quinn are strugg...
2 days ago
Wells Fargo to forego asset management unit to private equity for $2.1 billion

Wells Fargo to forego asset management unit to private equity for $2.1 billion

Wells Fargo has been underperforming for the past few years and has undertaken cost-cutting and restructuring to improve its numbers. Wells ...
2 days ago